Honest Pros and Cons of Living in Pinehurst


Honest Pros and Cons of Living in Pinehurst
Known for its picturesque landscapes and serene environment, Pinehurst, N.C., captures the charm of Southern living in every possible way. This small-town gem is not just a beloved retreat for golf enthusiasts but a vibrant community that brings together the tranquility of countryside living and the convenience of modern amenities. Pinehurst ranks among the state’s best places to retire, and its friendly confines appeal to families, professionals, and individuals from all walks of life.

But what truly makes Pinehurst stand out from other towns? Read on for a closer perspective at this haven of the South.

Pros of Living in Pinehurst

Before moving to Pinehurst, consider the following advantages and whether they apply to your lifestyle.


When considering a move to Pinehurst, understanding the local weather patterns is crucial in your decision-making process. The weather is perfect for year round activities from riding your horse to playing 18 holes (or more) of golf every day. We play golf here pretty much all the time…even if it rains….our sandy soil allows you to play minutes after a rainy day! The sandy soils are also kind to horses feet so many horses don’t wear shoes…a little savings in your pocket book from having the farrier come all the time! The town receives more sunny days per year than the national average — ideal for hundreds of rounds of golf per year or riding in the Walthour Moss Foundation to your heart’s content! Our “worst” months are the end of July and early August when it does get into the 90’s (not the 100’s)....so that is a great time to visit our wonderful mountains or our beaches!


Pinehurst, North Carolina is a world-renowned golf destination. It is home to eight courses designed by some of the most famous golf architects in the world, including Donald Ross, Charles Blair Macdonald, and Tom Fazio. The courses are known for their challenging layouts and stunning scenery.

Pinehurst has hosted numerous major championships, including the U.S. Open, the U.S. Women's Open, and the Ryder Cup. It is also a popular destination for amateur golfers and offers a variety of packages and lessons for all levels of players.

Economic stability

Economic stability is one of Pinehurst’s strong suits. The town has an above-average median income, suggesting a higher earning potential for residents and leading to a higher quality of life. The local economy is boosted by tourism, especially Pinehurst’s status as a bucket-list destination for golfers.

Luxury real estate

As of July 2023, Jamie McDevitt has access to over 100 properties in Pinehurst. The top decile of the local market has list prices of $1.1 million and above. Homes in Pinehurst range from large estates to cozy cottages, and prices vary depending on size, location, and amenities. Ask your real estate agent for insight into the most popular neighborhoods in town, which include Pinehurst Village, Country Club Estates, Mid Pines, and Southern Pines.


For foodies, there are many great Pinehurst restaurants to enjoy. The town’s dining scene reflects various cuisines, from authentic Italian and Indian to Southern-style cooking and innovative fusion food. With such a rich and diverse dining scene, Pinehurst ensures that every food lover finds something to suit their palate.

Here is a sampling of restaurants you should try in Pinehurst:


The significant amount of land covered by trees is a big draw for nature lovers. This high tree coverage offers a sense of tranquility and plenty of opportunities for outdoor activities. Of particular interest are the endangered longleaf pine trees that gave Pinehurst its name.


Pinehurst’s community is well-educated, providing an environment that values academic achievement. Learning is a priority and an advantage for families with young children. Elementary students in Pinehurst score well in math, reading, and language arts. Moore County Schools operates several top-rated schools, including Pinehurst Elementary School, West Pine Middle School, and Pinecrest High School.

Cons of Living in Pinehurst

The following aspects of Pinehurst may be detrimental to your enjoyment of the town.

Cost of living

Living in Pinehurst, North Carolina, has many perks, including a vibrant community and beautiful surroundings. However, it’s important to understand the cost of living in this area. Groceries, health-related expenses, and housing cost more than both national and state averages. Housing is particularly expensive (as you might expect for a growing community with luxury real estate).

Extreme weather conditions

Like many parts of the Southeast, Pinehurst is susceptible to severe storms. These can cause property damage and disrupt daily life, an aspect to consider when contemplating a move. Usually, though, the extent of extreme weather are occasional summer heat waves. You can also expect 47 inches of rain annually in Pinehurst. Most residents would agree the town’s mix of weather contributes to its charm.

High property prices

One of the main hurdles potential homeowners might face in Pinehurst is the relatively high property prices. This factor can potentially limit the pool of individuals able to afford homeownership in the area. However, the town’s reliable tourism industry means you can possibly rent your second home when not using it.

Private schools

Families who want a top-tier education for their children may decide to send them to private schools. Local options are somewhat limited and include Episcopal Day School, The O’Neal School, and Sandhills Classical Christian School. Consult your real estate agent for more details on local schools.

Work with Jamie McDevitt

In conclusion, moving to Pinehurst, North Carolina, depends largely on personal lifestyle preferences and priorities. The town offers a blend of Southern charm, academic enrichment, and economic stability, alongside a few challenges to consider. As with any major decision, potential residents should weigh the pros and cons to make the best choice for their needs and aspirations.

Jamie McDevitt owns and operates McDevitt Town and Country Properties, providing expert brokerage services. She has a knack for assisting clients in discovering their ideal urban or rural residences. Jamie’s past as a globally ranked tennis player and her ongoing engagement in competitive equestrian activities, golf, and swimming reflect her dynamic lifestyle.

Understanding her clients’ real estate objectives is Jamie’s forte. She works tirelessly to ensure they meet their goals. Her team is particularly attentive to clients relocating to Pinehurst and Southern Pines for various leisure pursuits, such as golf, tennis, horseback riding, or simply to savor neighborhood walks and runs.

Jamie’s determination to deliver the results her clients deserve epitomizes her unwavering dedication to their needs. If you’re looking to buy or sell a home or have questions about homes for sale in Pinehurst NC, contact Jamie McDevitt today.

*Header photo courtesy of Pinehurst Resort

Work With Jamie

Jamie will take the time to understand your goals and will work tirelessly to help you reach them. Whether you are moving to the Pinehurst, Southern Pines area to play golf, swing a tennis racket, or simply run or walk through your neighborhood, let Jamie work for you.